Summary
Peanutsis known for its heartwarming, gentle humor – which is why it might surprise fans to learn that creator Charles Schulz was incredibly competitive by nature. This led him toview the comic industry as a “fight” to dominate the attention of newspaper readers on a day-to-day basis, something he did for much of thefive decadesPeanutswas in publication.
David Michaelis' comprehensive account of the artist’s life and work,Schulz and Peanuts: A Biography, details Schulz’s surprisingly adversarial stance toward other cartoons, and cartoonists. It also proposes that his criticisms of other artists stemmed from the same origin as his own motivation to consistently produce the best work possible.
As much asPeanutscan beconsidered the greatest comic strip of all time, its legacy is a result of Schulz’s unrelenting drive to make every single strip the best it could be. At the same time, his need to be the best resulted in him viewing the medium through an intensely competitive lens.
10 Peanuts Comics That Are So Much Darker Than Fans Realized
While Peanuts may look happy and shiny on the surface, beneath the cutesy illustrations lie some dark moments from the gang and their beagle pals.
Charles Schulz Considered Every Day A “Fight” For Readers' Attention
The Funny Pages Were A “Competitive Arena”
Charles Schulz was a pioneering figure in the comic medium, but when others started to find similar success along the trail that he blazed, he became defensive of his position at the top of the industry.
David Michaelis’Schulz and Peanutsis expansive, in the manner of the best biographies. It effectively immerses readers in its subject’s story, crafting an in-depth account of Charles Schulz’s worldview, while also deftly navigating how he was perceived, and how he projected himself to others. A great example comes from the book’s description of the artist’s view of the comic industry, in which it is stated that he:
…regarded the comic pages as a competitive arena where, as he saw it, “each cartoonist fights for attention.
This may surprise some readers, considering the content ofPeanuts, but it goes far toward explainingCharles Schulz’s decades of dominance in the comic medium.
Michaelis then quoted author Cathy Guisewite, who spoke to how Schulz approached other comics, who said:
He read his rivals' strips “the way all cartoonists do, looking to see if they won, if they beat everyone else that day,” recalled cartoonist Cathy Guisewite, who once watched Schulz study the Sunday funnies in theSan Francisco Chronicle. “He liked to win on the page.”
It is interesting that Schulz’s fellow author attributes his attitude toward his peers as something common to “all cartoonists.” However, other passages throughoutSchulz and Peanutsmake it clear that it was also, to a large degree, an extension of the artist’s personal competitive streak.Charles Schulz was a pioneering figure in the comic medium, but when others started to find similar success along the trail that he blazed, he became defensive of his position at the top of the industry.
Cathy Guisewite is the creator of the comic stripCathy, which was published in syndication from 1976 through 2010.
This defensiveness made him a harsh critic of many other cartoons, andresulted in a complicated relationship between Schulz and many of his contemporaries, even the ones that he had a mentor-like relationship withto some degree or another. As described inSchulz and Peanuts, the artist had become accustomed to being the top cartoonist in the country duringPeanutsfirst several decades. When he began to have serious competition for readers' attention, it was from a generation of creators raised on his work, grateful for his influence, and often seeking his guidance – which he was at times hesitant to give.
Charles Schulz Deeply Competitive Nature Shaped Charlie Brown’s Character
A Proxy For His Creator’s Fear Of Failure
In order to succeed, it is often necessary to have a deep-seated fear of failure – something that, for Charles Schulz, manifested on the page in his protagonist Charlie Brown, one of the most iconic failures in literary history.
For Charles Schulz, “winning” was not just a matter of commercial success, nor was it aboutestablishingPeanutsas the all-time greatestin the medium. Instead, it was a daily battle – a competition that could be won or lost with every single comic strip he produced. As explained inSchulz and Peanuts:
It was not enough that he had “revolutionized the art form, deepening it, filling it with possibility, giving permission to all who followed to write from the heart and intellect,” as Garry Trudeau pointed out. It did not matter that he achieved a success of dreamlike dimensions, or that Peanuts had been the most popular comic for years in newspaper readers’ polls. Schulz had to get the better of everyone else on the comics page every day.
Victory, in other words, was a matter of being the best strip on the page any given day – and to Schulz, he was the ultimate arbiter of quality when it came to newspaper comics.
Michaelis further quoted Schulz as stating: “In the thing that I do best, which is drawing a comic strip, it is important to me that I win.” To Schulz, there was nothing subjective about what he did, and the winner and loser of a day’s comic page seemed like a clear-cut matter to him. It is a way of looking at art that does, admittedly, seem at odds with the worldview ofPeanuts, the one that afforded Schulz the success that he would later so fiercely protect. However, upon closer examination,Schulz’s drive to succeed is evident in the strip in subtle ways.
After all, to succeed, it is often necessary to have a deep-seated fear of failure –something that, for Charles Schulz, manifested on the page in his protagonist Charlie Brown,one of the most iconic failures in literary history. Though he worked diligently to givePeanutsa “timeless” and “innocent” quality,Schulz’s anxieties, feelings, and ideas about lifewere regularly filtered through the lens his characters, and his aversion to failure is among the most potently represented across the corpus ofPeanutsas a whole.
Garry Trudeau is the creator ofDoonesbury, which entered publication in 1970, with new comics still released to this day. Famously, Trudeau won a Pulitzer Prize forDoonesburyin 1975 – and perhaps infamously, Charles Schulz hated the strip for its use of overtly political humor.
Charles Schulz’s Creative Determination Led To A Five-Decade Career
He Refused To Quit
Not only did Schulz resist giving up direct creative control ofPeanuts, he was constantly “consciously striving to be a better cartoonist,” even at the height of his game. In essence, this was what kept him operating at such a high level for so long.
Schulz and Peanutsauthor David Michaelis effectively sums up the unyielding nature of Charles Schulz’s artistic drive by highlighting that, at a certain point in his career, he didn’t need to keep drawingPeanuts. Michaelis wrote:
As the creator of the most widely syndicated cartoon on the planet, read by 5 percent of the world’s literate population and watched in animated television specials by more than 4.4 billion viewers over the previous twenty-five years, [Schulz] could have maintained his presence at the top just by hiring a team of assistants to ring changes on his themes, but instead he made a strict point of getting himself to the drawing board every morning and consciously striving to be a better cartoonist.
Not only did Schulz resist giving up direct creative control ofPeanuts, he was constantly “consciously striving to be a better cartoonist,” even at the height of his game. In essence, this was what kept himoperating at such a high levelfor so long.
It was this constant impulse to be at the top, for Charles Schulz, that gave his career meaning. Had he not approached cartooning with such a competitive mindset, he might very well have retired from cartooning decades beforePeanutsended with his death in 2000. The strip could have continued in his absence, but it wouldn’t have been what it once was – and that was something Schulz could not abide by. Not when he felt he could still out-perform every other comic artist in America.
ForPeanutsfans,learning about Charles Schulz’s competitiveness offers added context for understanding his work.Whatever the disconnect between the art and the artist might be, it is worth exploring the creative mind that produced one of themost influential, long-running serial works of fictionof the past century. Knowing that his motivation was often to stay ahead of his “rivals” casts a new light on the humorPeanuts, allowing it to be revisited and reinterpreted from a different perspective, something that is always worthwhile.
Source:Schulz and Peanuts: A Biography
Peanuts
Created by Charles M. Schulz, Peanuts is a multimedia franchise that began as a comic strip in the 1950s and eventually expanded to include films and a television series. Peanuts follows the daily adventures of the Peanuts gang, with Charlie Brown and his dog Snoopy at the center of them. Aside from the film released in 2015, the franchise also has several Holiday specials that air regularly on U.S. Television during their appropriate seasons.
